‘Us vs Them’ (Neighbors) Attitude?

I remain in favor of new athletic fields for our youth – as long as there are mitigations and protections for the community. School board members unfortunately decided on an “Us versus Them” (the neighbors) attitude. Working out details with area residents cooperatively would have been a much more positive approach. Nuisances can be lowered and hazards minimized. Board members: Were your listening to public testimony? Did you truly consider the details in submitted community response regarding increased noise, 90 foot-high light fixtures, and fire hazard? There have been two fires that originated on Canyon Middle School grounds in recent years – the last one in 2023. With increased use (5X existing number of students and adults who use the campus), there will be increased fire danger. Last December the consultant you hired falsely stated that there would be no increased usage. Come on. The Mitigated Negative Declaration prepared by them (Place Works) conveniently omitted this from their study. Let’s have some integrity. Please. Litigation is expensive. When the next fire happens, the canyon lands mostly school property (and immediately adjacent to the proposed fields) could experience fire. Scores of surrounding homes would be at increased risk. Don’t gloss over this, or use hyperbole, or be condescending. Board members: We are your neighbors. You have an opportunity to set a fine example of Doing Things Right.

–Richard Adams, Castro Valley